My church will replace our Black Lives Matter sign. Will America replace its racist myth?
The Rev. William H. Lamar IV is the pastor of the Metropolitan African Methodist Episcopal Church in Washington.
Do you hear what I hear? I hear the imperial American myth in the throes of its own death rattle. And I hear a people
clamoring for a story by which to order their lives.
The United States does not like to call itself an empire. But it is. Through military and economic force, the United
States extends its narrative, politics and culture throughout the globe for good and for ill. The American story to which
I refer does not shape our domestic life alone. It shapes the world.
Myths, stories, give our lives meaning. They tell us who we were, who we are and who we will be.
The myth of the American imperium is deeply rooted in falsehoods and forgetfulness, in intentional historical amnesia
and obfuscation. Liberty was not the founding American impulse; genocide was. The blessing of God did not secure
this nation’s prosperity. The forced labor of my ancestors did. The founders were not committed to a republic or a
democracy. They were committed to a racialized plutocracy led by propertied White males.
Everyone else was excluded by law, custom and violence.
A sign came down on Saturday. The Black Lives Matter banner in front of Metropolitan African Methodist Episcopal
Church, where I am privileged to serve as pastor, was removed and destroyed on Saturday evening. I am deeply
disturbed by this incident (one of several incidents targeting houses of worship), but I am more disturbed by the
continued mythology of imperial America. This mythology supports those who commit violence against human beings
for political ends, deny citizens their right to vote, denigrate sacred spaces and claim as their own whatever they
It mattered not that the land was ours. It mattered not that the sign was ours. The mythology that motivated the
perpetrators on Saturday night was the underbelly of the American narrative — that White men can employ violence to
take what they want and do what they want and call that criminality justice, freedom and liberty.
That is the history written into this nation, into the bodies of those brutalized by this mythology, and carried forth in
this moment by human beings who have been malformed by a story of scarcity that precludes their own flourishing
and the flourishing of others.
conspiracy theory that gains purchase, with every refusal to protect the vulnerable from the coronavirus unless
corporations are protected first. The political imagination of this entire nation is captive to a white-supremacist myth.
Only a new narrative can change the way we order this society.
This new narrative must question everything if we are serious about imagining a better world. The media, academia
and religious institutions alike often behave as if American capitalism was decreed by the divine. The economic
infrastructure of this nation generates inhumane inequality. Religious fundamentalists believe in individual sin while
turning a blind eye to the sinfulness of an economic system that forces working people to pay more of their income in
taxes while refusing to pay them living wages, that deprives them of health care and humane retirements. And all this
happens while the rich grow richer.
Those who ripped down our sign — whether they are aware of it or not — suffer from kleptocratic, crony capitalism in
the United States. What they really want is a new narrative and a new politics. What we must do is the hard work of
creating this new narrative — one that tells a true story of humans thriving together and sharing the abundance of the
land and their labor.
As a preacher, I view what happened in the yard of our church as a showdown between the God of the universe, the
God of all people, the God incarnate in Jesus Christ, and the god of white supremacy.
One God is for all. The other god is for some. One God has chosen humanity. The other god has chosen whiteness,
imperialism and human subjugation.
The men and women who founded the African Methodist Episcopal Church knew and were known by the God of all
people. Metropolitan is rooted in this theological vision that humankind is one family. There have been outposts of
resistance to the god of white supremacy from the beginning. These institutions must lead the way toward a new
narrative. And white-supremacist institutions must assume the role of student, not teacher.
The United States of America must abandon this god, this story and the violence that flows from fidelity to the same.
A sign came down on Saturday. Metropolitan will replace the sign.
Will the United States replace the story that makes such acts of desecration inevitable?